We receive phone calls regularly from people who want to sell their investment property and, of course, they want to fetch market value for it. These phone calls become heightened after we disclose a record breaking sale such as our most recent one at 233 Wychwood Avenue listed at $989,000 which sold for $1,208,500. Of course every caller insists that their investment property is also worth the same or more than 233 Wychwood Avenue because the market is “very hot”.
It is true that the investment property market is very strong but unlike single family homes whose ultimate high sold price can reflect an element of emotion, investment property sold prices are influenced more by an investment return. A huge factor that will determine market value for your property will be the income it generates.
During these conversations we probe deeper and ask many questions about the condition of the property and especially about the income it generates before we voice our opinion on value. The caller usually answers “well the rent is low but I like my tenant” or “the rent is low but my tenant has been here for a long time” or “I have a really good tenant who takes care of the property so I have given him/her a reduced rent”.
So then we respond “that’s really nice that you have a good tenant, but an investor who will pay you market value for your property also expects market value rents”. They respond “well they can always ask the tenant to leave”.
In reality a new owner cannot ask the tenant to leave and being a landlord you should know this. A tenant can only be asked to vacate, if they do not have a lease, and under these circumstances:
As you can see a new buyer cannot arbitrarily “get rid of a tenant”. Then these callers keep insisting that their property generating a cap rate of 2% to 3% is worth the same as one that generates a 5% cap rate simply because the market is hot. Unfortunately that is not the case. In reality if you have two identical properties in the exact same location in similar condition with one generating an annual net income of $50,000 while the other an annual net income of $40,000, the property generating the higher net income will sell for a much higher price.
So what can you do to ensure that your investment property will increase in value according to the market?
Time and time again we list tenanted properties and of course they require tenant co-operation for viewing times and presentation of the property. Many sellers will say “oh my tenant will be very co-operative and flexible because I’ve been so good to them over the years by keeping their rent low etc” only to witness, after the landlord tells the tenant they are selling, an overly uncooperative tenant or one that insists you abide by the letter of the law. Most tenants do not appreciate the possibility of being displaced whether you have been good to them or not so treat it like a business because most tenants assuredly will. Furthermore align yourself with a trustworthy real estate agent who will advice you properly on how to go about maximizing the resale value of your investment.